Handmade in small batches with high-grade European chocolate, Arabica cold brew coffee and pure dairy, Coop’s Cold Brew Mocha Sauce is a jar of ooey-gooey nostalgia. Deep and dark with a balanced hint of java, this indulgent sauce has just the right touch of sweetness—unlike other sugary versions that leave an artificial taste on your tongue.

It’s instantly rich and impeccably smooth, thick right out of the jar but drizzly once warmed. Atop ice cream it hardens to the perfect soft chew, but we don’t stop there—spread it on brownies, drip it over fruit, plunge your pretzels into it or devour it straight by the spoonful. Just don’t be surprised if it disappears quickly.